Presentation: 9
Excellent production values, but a few holes persist.
Graphics: 9.5
It doesn't get much better than this, and the bevy of options make things highly customizable to your rig's capabilities.
Sound: 9.5
Gorgeous music, spooky ambient sound, and great sound effects abound.
Gameplay: 9.2
Challenging combat, great set pieces, detailed environments, but not a lot of environmental variety.
Lasting Appeal: 8
The main game is relatively short; multiplayer, while having some neat tricks up its sleeve, won't replace Counter-Strike any time soon.
OVERALL: 9.2